3 Reasons Why Your Marketing Isn’t Converting

Patrick McFadden

You can go a long way with relationships and great information, but if you’re trying to build a business, at some point you need to actually tell your audience what to do and that will usually be to buy something.

Getting a shopper to your website, to your store or wherever you do business is only half the battle in business. You have to convert that shopper into a customer to stay in business.

So, today we’re going to talk about that: why your marketing isn’t converting . Conversion is the point when your shopper either buys or doesn’t buy, based on your communication of good feelings and/or solutions to their problems.

Let’s talk about the three most common reasons that your shoppers aren’t turning into buyers. There are many reasons why your marketing isn’t converting , but these are by far the most common.

1. They are not interested

This is by-far the most painful reason. But if this is the case and what’s wrong, there’s no marketing technique in the world that will help you out.

Sometimes you (even myself) just get really passionate about an idea that our customers aren’t nearly as passionate about.

This was the case for Otto Rohwedder, who invented sliced bread. He did as most inventors do, and only focused on the patent and making part. So, for the first fifteen years his idea of slice bread was a complete failure. Until wonder bread came along and marketed the idea. Then customers wanted slice bread and paid for slice bread.

This brings up another great point, you might have a widget or an idea you’re convinced your customers need, but is it something they want.

When in doubt, know that “wants” win over “needs” every time.

2. They don’t trust you

At the heart of every transaction is trust. After #1, this is the second most important reason.

They may want what you offer. They may have thoughts of how they’re going to use it. They may even know just what to do next.

But they don’t pull the trigger.

Why?

Because they’re second-guessing their decision, and they’re scared of looking and feeling like they’ve been taken — like an idiot.

Don’t take it personally — we’re living in an age of betrayal. Madoff made off will other people’s money. Baseball players are lying about testing positive. Companies lay-off staff to increase quarterly stock price evaluation.

So how are they going to trust you?

You build up trust by creating strong business relationships with relevant and valuable information that solves problems.

3. You didn’t ask for the order

This reason why your marketing isn’t converting  is my favorite, because it’s the easiest to fix.

I realize it seems simplistic, but if you enthusiastically ask your shopper to click the link, visit our store, dial the 800-number, or whatever other vehicle you use to get that sale, he or she is much more likely to do it. Weird, but true.

It’s called the call to action, and every business needs a very compelling one. If you’re not familiar with the call to action, or you need some examples of how it’s done, here’s an article I wrote on it:

Question: Do you think you could benefit from any of the advice above? What is it?

Click here to subscribe today (at no charge) and get instant updates to proven marketing advice dripped out to you via email.

Of course, if it’s not for you, you can unsubscribe with just a couple of clicks. And we’ll never rent or share your information with anyone.)

By Patrick McFadden April 18, 2025
Understanding platform intent, sales cycles, and what actually works in high-ticket home services
By Patrick McFadden March 31, 2025
1. The Challenge: VMI was like many service providers — positioning their value around what they thought clients wanted : “Office furniture installation and assembly — let us handle creating your perfect workspace.” But the actual buyers — facility managers, project managers, furniture reps — weren’t looking for “perfect workspaces.” They were trying to avoid installation nightmares . Their real priority? ✅ Great installation days. ✅ No chaos. ✅ No missed deadlines. ✅ No angry phone calls from clients. 2. The Insight: After conducting stakeholder interviews under our marketing strategy consulting engagement , the Indispensable Marketing team uncovered critical feedback: “We need installers who maintain a professional site and follow instructions.” “We lose relationships when installations go badly.” “I need quotes back quickly or I can’t sell the job.” This wasn’t just about services , it was about trust, problem-solving , and professional reliability . So we reframed their differentiators not by what they did, but how they showed up : Same-day project quotes Problem-solving on-site Update protocol with clients Professionalism guarantee Lasting Impression Insurance 3. The Shift: We shifted the positioning from vague benefits to real-world, emotional triggers : Instead of: “Let us create your perfect workspace.” Now: “Get the perfect installation day, every time.” That subtle shift aligns with who’s actually buying (and who feels the pain when things go wrong). The end-user may care about the workspace. But the buyer cares about the install . 4. The Lesson for Others: If you’re selling a service, don’t describe what you do. Describe what the client wants to avoid or achieve — and who the real buyer is. Then, systematize what you’re already doing well and give it a name. Just like our team did with: “Same Day Quotes” “Lasting Impression Insurance” “Reliable Presence Protocol” 5. The Outcome Within weeks of updating their messaging and positioning: The company reported more qualified leads asking the right questions Furniture reps began referring them because they were “easy to work with and made them look good” They were shortlisted for larger, multi-phase projects due to increased confidence in their process But most importantly, they stopped competing on price — because they weren’t selling perfect workspaces anymore. They were selling peace of mind on installation day.
By Patrick McFadden March 8, 2025
Most marketing firms talk about tactics. We help our clients see the bigger picture.
More Posts