A Marketer’s Guide to Psychology

Patrick McFadden

What can marketers — anyone with something to say or sell — learn from the field of Psychology?

Simply said, “how to convert visitors into leads, and leads into customers.”

One key to being a great marketer is understanding how — and why — other people think and act the way they do. After all, when you seek to inspire people to take action — buy your product or services, like your FB page, follow you on twitter, sign-up for a demo, subscribe to your list, or watch a video — knowing their desires and problems is invaluable.

Here are tried and true lessons from Psychology that every marketer should know. It’s truly a marketer’s guide to psychology. Take a look:

Reciprocity  ―   The concept of “reciprocity” is simple — if you help someone, they’ll naturally want to help you. So reward your consumers with freebies and rewards, and they’ll reward you with their continued loyalty.

“You can have everything in life that you want if you just give enough other people what they want.”― Zig Ziglar

Authority   Your identity―how you’re known―as an authority will make your customers more likely to trust and buy your service or product. If you’ve got it, flaunt it. Let your audience know exactly what credentials you’re holding. What if you’re just starting and have no credibility? Hire a spokesman who does.

“People trust and like to buy from experts.” ― Jay Conrad Levinson

Social Proof —  You may have read about the way group thinking effects individual actions. In the case of “social proof,” it comes down to a situation in which your customers adopt the beliefs or actions of a group of people they like or trust. Let your consumer know what others are saying about your service and product, and make it easier to share your content on social channels.

“What would change the mind of many people resistant to evidence is a series of eager testimonials.” ― Seth Godin

Scarcity —  People want what they can’t have. This psychology principle goes back to the simple formula of supply and demand: the more rare the opportunity, content, service or product is, the more valuable it is. Stress your service or products limited availability and you’ll be sure to increase sales.

First, understand that scarcity is a choice. If you raise your price, scarcity goes away. If your product is going to be scarce, it’s either because you benefit from that or because your organization is forbidden to use price as a demand-adjustment tool.― Seth Godin

Recency Illusion —  Ever learn a new word, or bought a new car only to suddenly find it at every turn? That’s the recency illusion, and it applies to marketing. Develop consistent and repetitious marketing campaigns rather than fragmented “shotgun” ads. People will notice the campaign more after they’ve first been introduced to it.

Marketing works best through repetition. Just like advertising, marketing works best through repetition. Just like advertising, marketing works best through repetition. Just like advertising, marketing works best through repetition. Get the point?― Patrick McFadden

Commitments —  People don’t like breaking their promises. If someone commits to something — whether it is sending you an email, a meeting for lunch or signing up for your product demo, they feel like they’ve made an obligation to you. Once they make that commitment, people will be much less likely to bail.

Know that a mediocre marketing with commitment will always prove more profitable than a brilliant marketing without commitment.—Anonymous

Verbatim Effect —  We naturally condense information in our memory. A compelling speech is often reduced to a “fuzzy blur” wherein we remember a few key concepts.  If you’re speaking, writing, or teaching pack as much information into the headline as you can. If you’re on major media medium, aim for short, compelling soundbites.

“Shorter is better.”—Jim Estill

Whether you’re looking to communicate your brand’s message on TV, radio, online or out-of-home, these concepts are worth remembering.

Bonus: if you understand these principles and weave them into your marketing, you’ll also have “ The Mindset NEEDED to Win.”

Question: What psychology concepts do you use in your every-day marketing?

By Patrick McFadden March 31, 2025
1. The Challenge: VMI was like many service providers — positioning their value around what they thought clients wanted : “Office furniture installation and assembly — let us handle creating your perfect workspace.” But the actual buyers — facility managers, project managers, furniture reps — weren’t looking for “perfect workspaces.” They were trying to avoid installation nightmares . Their real priority? ✅ Great installation days. ✅ No chaos. ✅ No missed deadlines. ✅ No angry phone calls from clients. 2. The Insight: After conducting stakeholder interviews under our marketing strategy consulting engagement , the Indispensable Marketing team uncovered critical feedback: “We need installers who maintain a professional site and follow instructions.” “We lose relationships when installations go badly.” “I need quotes back quickly or I can’t sell the job.” This wasn’t just about services , it was about trust, problem-solving , and professional reliability . So we reframed their differentiators not by what they did, but how they showed up : Same-day project quotes Problem-solving on-site Update protocol with clients Professionalism guarantee Lasting Impression Insurance 3. The Shift: We shifted the positioning from vague benefits to real-world, emotional triggers : Instead of: “Let us create your perfect workspace.” Now: “Get the perfect installation day, every time.” That subtle shift aligns with who’s actually buying (and who feels the pain when things go wrong). The end-user may care about the workspace. But the buyer cares about the install . 4. The Lesson for Others: If you’re selling a service, don’t describe what you do. Describe what the client wants to avoid or achieve — and who the real buyer is. Then, systematize what you’re already doing well and give it a name. Just like our team did with: “Same Day Quotes” “Lasting Impression Insurance” “Reliable Presence Protocol” 5. The Outcome Within weeks of updating their messaging and positioning: The company reported more qualified leads asking the right questions Furniture reps began referring them because they were “easy to work with and made them look good” They were shortlisted for larger, multi-phase projects due to increased confidence in their process But most importantly, they stopped competing on price — because they weren’t selling perfect workspaces anymore. They were selling peace of mind on installation day.
By Patrick McFadden March 8, 2025
Most marketing firms talk about tactics. We help our clients see the bigger picture.
By Patrick McFadden January 13, 2025
Discover how Google’s LSA update impacts kitchen & bathroom remodeling marketing. Learn SEO tips to attract leads and boost visibility in Richmond VA & beyond.
More Posts
Share by: